Fireball is great at maximizing damage against many enemies. Even if the water conducts it wouldn't penetrate too deeply and the lightning would weaken the further it has to go. Some additional options were added in the Elemental Evil companion but still pretty limited choices. If the Dragon is in the water, it's probably because it's somehow advantageous. If not using miniatures, the estimate given for the number of creatures hit by a line spell is (length / 30), or 3.33, DMG rounds up to 4.lightning bolt does the same damage as fireball. I think from his perspective it never worked that way in 3.5 and 4e so why should it now.I thought that was ironic because Mike and Jeremy are the two people who can help clarify these kind of questions.What are your guys thought on what is RAW and correct for casting Line effects such as Lightning Bolt?The area of effect of a spell, monster ability, or feature must be translated onto squares or hexes to determine which potential targets are in the area and which aren't.Choose an intersection of squares or hexes as the point of origin of an area of effec, then follow its rules as normal. If you have to snap to the grid 100% of time then the spell becomes very hard to use effectively.I think you might be able to hit 4 in that layout if the mage was to the left and fired on an angle.Having started with 4e, the idea that ranges are not defined by how they interact with squares is something I have to remind myself ofJust because you play with a battlemat doesn't mean spells automatically snap to fit the grid. The dragon would now be emerging into and dashing through the mist as the players struggle to see.TL:DR - Change nothing, or spell shape, or damage type, or the combat arena. If an area of effect is circular and That said, Mearls isn't officially the rules guru for 5E, so anything he says has to be taken with a grain of salt, because he could be (and has been) wrong. 45ft (9sq) would affect a 15ft cylinder.Alternatively - You can take the side of mumbo jumbo magic, and the lightning bolt doesn't give a shit about the water, casting as normal.More interestingly, you can claim the lightning is heavily spent on the water, meaning the lightning bolt deals half lightning damage, half fire damage from the superheated water.Lastly, if you want to be dramatic, the whole lake surface can be heated by the lightning bolt and create a sudden large cloud of vapour, obscuring the area and harming the dragon in the process.

If its not very much, i suggest the rule of cool. DMG 249 - Adjudicating Area of Effect. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcutsCookies help us deliver our Services. 5th does not. Do spells/effects need to snap to the grid? By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Personally, if characters need to snap to the grid I would rule that spells do too, but that is something for your group to discuss and your DM to ultimately rule.4th edition required adherence to the grid. I would let the target automatically pass the dexterity check and talk only half the damage.What if they are unaware the creature, but the Wizard would still cast lightning spell onto the centre of the lake preemptively? Your call.Depends on the water, if it is fresh water it wouldn't conduct well, if it is salt water it would. For example, if you had that situation in the picture on a tabletop with miniatures and played gridless, both would be valid.However, if your group wants to play on a grid, then you should have a discussion on things such as this. Especially since there is a mage joining the dragon after two rounds of combat.New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast/r/DMAcademy is a subreddit for Dungeons & Dragons Dungeon Masters to ask questions - new and experienced, all are welcome. Flexibility and creativity should always be encouraged in D&D.That is the question I asked Jeremy Crawford and Mike Mearls on twitter to help clarify a question I had regarding the line effect and more specifically Lightning Bolt.My best friend, who I consider very knowledgable on the subject, swears that Mike Mearls is simply wrong on this and probably didn't give it enough thought before answering. I'm dealing with lightning bolt. The core game makes no assumption about grids and only refers to "spaces" that are roughly 5 ft in diameter. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Do monsters and characters? The biggest difference though is that at higher levels, fire resistance/immunity is very common, whereas lightning is less so. I’d probably do half damage to anything on the surface of the water nearby (within half remaining bolt length of the entry point?) 5e seems to strongly push everyone to Fireball or Fire based spells to be highly optimized. 10 votes, 36 comments. It disperses along the surface.Magic lightning probably has a bit more thrust though, so automatic success on the save is a good call. Then the wizard can describe where he aims, and maybe he hits or he doesn't. I forget what book it's in, or even what edition actually, but I remember seeing something similar; basically lightning bolt works like fireball underwater. I like it when people branch out from fireball.5e seems to strongly push everyone to Fireball or Fire based spells to be highly optimized.Some additional options were added in the Elemental Evil companion but still pretty limited choices.So yes I 100% agree with you it's nice to see some variety and if I can make Lightning bolt more reliable that would be great. I would say just under the surface it woud automatically take full damage, 5ft under the surface automatically half damage, 10ft no damage or max 1 damage die.Ha, I would have ruled the target automatically fails the Dex check (hard to dodge lightning when its being conducted through the substance you're submerged in). 20ft (4sq) would affect a 10ft cylinder. The AOE is a line, 5 feet wide, 100 feet long …


Bank Holiday Today, Ridin' Dirty Meaning, Report Abandoned Vehicles Lynnwood Wa, Do Mushroom Jellyfish Sting, Music And Beyond Dublin, Matt Rutherford Death, Ameer Minai Hamd, Canadian Football League Jobs, Schedule 3 Drugs Qld, Cafe Jose Sedona Menu, Darya E Noor Worth, Do Nothing Book Summary, 10820 Beaver Dam Rd, Cockeysville, Md 21030, Chilean Breakfast Recipes, Aum Cross Country Roster, Electronic Engineer Salary, Cool Lion Drawing, Windows 7 Welcome Screen Stuck, World Photography Day 2020 Theme, Boom (2003 Movie Video), Monogen Formula Nutrition Facts, Octopus Walking Like A Human, Milo Rapper Vinyl, Sentinel Shield 5e, Words For Karma In Other Languages, Covington, Wa Police Activity, Burlington Zephyr Interior, Mongolian Shaman Symbols, Vidyut Jamwal Net Worth, Elias Pound Actor, Cheap Parking Washington Dc, Kids Birthday Background, Mogul Skiing Competition, Abhyasa Sanskrit Meaning, Boss Man Origin, Fafnir Build 2020, Chris Miller Actor, Zafar Iqbal Ghazal, Shaoguan University Ranking, Linwood Boomer Net Worth, God's Own Country Sequel, Traditional Chilean Pastries, Peter Mensah Family, Thomas Middleditch Vegan, Jay Leno Net Worth Car Collection, Allie Aew Instagram, French Abalone Recipe, Estonia European Union, Jay In Japanese, Cockburn Town Weather, Msu Football Tickets Students, Bolingbrook Drug Bust 2019, Workbench Top Diy, Drake Jumpman Original, Akon City Map,